Ranked · Updated May 2026
The 10 Best Tattoo Shops in New Albany, IN
Ranked top 10 for New Albany, IN — scored by rating, review volume, and distance from New Albany. Updated weekly. See the full Louisville top 10.
Finding a tattoo artist near New Albany usually means weighing two things at once: how good the shop actually is, and how far you're realistically willing to drive for it. This guide solves both. We pulled every verified studio within 15 miles of New Albany, then ranked them against the wider Louisville market using the same star ratings, review volume, and proximity signals locals already trust — no pay-to-play, no sponsored slots.
New Albany sits inside the Louisville tattoo scene, which means residents get the benefit of big-city talent without big-city wait times. The shops below range from neighborhood walk-in studios to appointment-only specialists known across IN for custom work. Whether you're booking your first piece or adding to a full sleeve, the list is ordered to put the strongest match for New Albany at the top.
What to expect from this list
- Verified ratings only. Every shop has real review history — we exclude studios with no public track record.
- Distance from New Albany. Each listing shows exact mileage so you can balance quality against drive time.
- Style tags. Filter by what you actually want inked — fine line, traditional, blackwork, realism, Japanese, and more.
- Booking signals. We flag walk-in availability, price tier, and direct links to each studio's site and Instagram.
- Refreshed weekly. Rankings move as new reviews land — no stale "best of 2019" lists.
- No.1
Bananafish Tattoo Parlour
4.9(317)In New Albany$$Our top pick for New Albany — right in New Albany, with 317 verified reviews averaging 4.9★.
- No.2
Th'Inker Tattoos
4.9(761)1.6 mi from New Albany$$Th'Inker Tattoos is a tattoo studio in New Albany.
- No.3
Ye olde Lick & Stick Tattoo company
4.7(183)1.0 mi from New Albany$$Ye olde Lick & Stick Tattoo company is a tattoo studio in New Albany.
- No.4
Retrograde Studio
5.0(25)In New Albany$$Retrograde Studio is a tattoo studio in New Albany.
- No.5
Pale Moon Tattoo
4.9(153)1.6 mi from New Albany$$Pale Moon Tattoo is a tattoo studio in New Albany.
- No.6
North Star Tattoo Co.
4.8(70)1.2 mi from New Albany$$North Star Tattoo Co.
- No.7
Equinox Tattoo Studio
5.0(14)In New Albany$$Equinox Tattoo Studio is a tattoo studio in New Albany.
- No.8
Xtreme Ink and Piercing
4.6(545)3.6 mi from New Albany$$Xtreme Ink and Piercing is a tattoo studio in Louisville.
- No.9
Magnolia Tattoo Company
5.0(4)In New Albany$$Magnolia Tattoo Company is a tattoo studio in New Albany.
- No.10
Tatt-Hues & Co by Brandi Jo
5.0(18)1.1 mi from New Albany$$Tatt-Hues & Co by Brandi Jo is a tattoo studio in New Albany.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best tattoo shop near New Albany, IN?+
Based on rating, review count, and proximity, Bananafish Tattoo Parlour ranks #1 for New Albany. The full list is ranked by a combination of star average, review volume, and distance from New Albany.
Are these shops actually in New Albany?+
We include studios within roughly 15 miles of New Albany — the realistic radius most people drive for a tattoo appointment. Each listing shows its distance and neighborhood so you can pick what's convenient.
How much do tattoos cost near New Albany?+
Most reputable studios in the Louisville area charge $150–$250 per hour for custom work, with shop minimums around $80–$120. Specialists and well-known artists routinely run $300+ per hour. Always confirm pricing during your consultation.
How often is this list updated?+
Our shop data refreshes weekly — ratings, review counts, and rankings reflect the most recent verified data from each studio.
Looking beyond New Albany?
See every top-rated shop across the Louisville metro — ranked by reviews and verified weekly.
Top 10 in Louisville